Search Content

  • All
  • Articles
  • Journals
  • Authors
  • Issues
Begin your search to discover academic resources...
Begin your search to discover academic resources...
No journals curated for this search.
No academic authors found matching this query.
No journal issues found matching this query.

Issue Information

Vol. 25 Issue 2

Published on: November 20, 2026

  • 32 Views
  • 7 Downloads
  • 0 Citations

Published on November 20, 2026

Strengthening Social Work Field Placements in Malawi: Perspectives from Practice Educators and Field Supervisors

Authors

Ausrin Ndala * University of Malawi 0009-0004-5933-1119

Abstract

Field placement is widely regarded as the pedagogical cornerstone of social work education, yet in emerging professional contexts, its effectiveness depends less on its formal inclusion in curricula than on the institutional arrangements that sustain it. This article argues that in Malawi, the central challenge facing social work field education is not simply its relative newness, but the absence of a coherent, standardised, and collaboratively governed practicum system. Drawing on qualitative data from 24 practice educators and field supervisors who participated in a national training workshop held in Liwonde in May 2024, the study employs thematic analysis to examine how field education is currently organised and experienced. The findings reveal a fragmented system characterised by five interrelated weaknesses: the lack of harmonised practicum frameworks across universities; weak communication and feedback loops between training institutions and host agencies; burdensome and inefficient administrative processes; unclear role expectations for students and supervisors; and limited institutional collaboration. These gaps are structural, reflecting an underdeveloped professional framework for social work training in Malawi. The article contends that meaningful reform requires the establishment of nationally coordinated social work standards and an integrated model of field supervision that aligns universities, regulatory bodies, and practice agencies. Such a shift is essential for consolidating the professionalisation of social work and ensuring that field placements function as effective sites of learning, accountability, and practice formation.

Keywords: Malawi, social work field education, field placement, supervision, professionalisation, social work standards

Introduction

Field education, also known as field practicum, field placement, field instruction, or fieldwork, is widely recognised as the signature pedagogy of social work education (Bogo, 2015). During field education, students are placed in social work agencies and exposed to the practice-based component of their training. It gives students supervised opportunities to integrate classroom theory with practice, which is crucial for developing their professional skills (Bogo, 2015). The global standards for social work education and training recommend that at least a quarter of a social work programme’s curriculum should consist of practice-based learning (Ioakimidis and Sookraj, 2021). This practice-based component is also reflected in the international definition of social work, which presents social work as ‘a practice-based profession and an academic discipline’ (IFSW, 2014). This underlines the importance of practice-based learning to social work education and to the profession.

In Malawi, social work is a relatively young field, with formal undergraduate education and training introduced only in the past decade. The University of Malawi was the first public university to offer a social work programme (Kakowa, 2016; Ndala, 2025). Its first placement, a two-week observational placement, took place in 2013, and its first full semester-long placement took place in 2015 (Kakowa, 2016; Ndala, 2025). The University of Malawi follows a block placement model, which concentrates periods of practice after coursework (Islam, 2024). At the time of writing, University of Malawi social work students spend two semesters and two weeks on placement, with structured formative and summative assessments implemented jointly by the university, field supervisors, and practice educators. Other institutions, such as the Catholic University of Malawi and DMI – St. John the Baptist University (DMISJBU), use shorter and less structured placement and assessment models (Wizi-Kambala, 2024). These variations reveal inconsistencies in how universities in Malawi implement placements, in duration, supervision, and assessment, and raise questions about the comparability of graduate competencies across institutions. Addressing these shortcomings would improve field placements and students’ learning experiences, regardless of the university they attend.

Practice educators and field supervisors are key stakeholders in the delivery of field practicum. They play a crucial role in shaping the quality of field education. In this study, a practice educator is a social work professional assigned by the university to support student social workers in practice, including with any learning-related challenges they face. A field supervisor, by contrast, is an employee of the agency in which students are placed, assigned by the agency to familiarise students with its work and its social work-related activities. In Malawi, most field supervisors are also trained as practice educators, for convenience and to reduce costs. As key stakeholders, practice educators and field supervisors can offer feedback that is critical for strengthening student field learning and supervision systems, and for informing national discussions on the professionalisation of social work.

Against this backdrop, this study draws on feedback gathered from 24 practice educators and field supervisors from across Malawi during a structured training and consultation workshop. Their reflections offer a grounded understanding of existing challenges and of opportunities for improving social work field education in Malawi. The central question that guided this inquiry was: How can social work field placements in Malawi be strengthened to ensure quality, consistency, and professional relevance across institutions?

The article is structured as follows. After this introduction, the next section outlines the theoretical and conceptual framework guiding the analysis. This is followed by a review of international, regional, and national literature on social work field education, and then by the methodology, which describes the study design, participants, data collection, and analysis. The findings section presents the five themes identified from participants’ feedback, and the discussion interprets them in light of existing scholarship and the theoretical framework. The article ends with recommendations for policy, academia, and practice, and a conclusion.

Field Education as a Signature Pedagogy and a Community of Practice

Two lenses frame this article. Shulman’s (2005) idea of signature pedagogy explains what field education is meant to do. Lave and Wenger’s (1991) communities of practice explain how that learning happens and who must sustain it. Read together, they shift the question. The issue is not whether Malawi has field placements. It is whether the arrangements around those placements allow them to work.

Shulman (2005) conceptualised signature pedagogy as the core mode of instruction through which a profession socialises students into its values, skills and practice expectations. In social work, field education plays this role. Students learn by engaging with real clients in real-life situations, within complex organisational contexts, and with real ethical dilemmas (Bogo, 2015). The literature consistently presents field education as central to social work education and crucial in preparing students for professional practice (Bogo, 2010; Bogo, 2015; Farber and Reitmeier, 2019; Drolet et al., 2024). Wayne et al. (2010) go further and name it the signature pedagogy of the profession. But a signature pedagogy is only as strong as its structure. If supervision, assessment, placement duration and agency support vary from one placement to the next, the socialising function of the placement weakens. Skeen (2023) puts the point bluntly by asking whether the claim is rhetoric or reality.

The international evidence suggests the gap is real. Studies report inadequate placement preparation, limited university support for students and practice educators, scarce resources, poor communication between universities and field educators, and inconsistent supervision (Bogo et al., 2022; Drolet et al., 2023). Others point to heavy documentation and administrative demands, difficulties in integrating theory and practice, and poorly structured student assessment (Wayne et al., 2010; Bogo et al., 2022; Skeen, 2023). These are not failures of pedagogy in the narrow sense. They are failures in the relationships and systems through which the pedagogy is delivered.

This is where communities of practice become useful. Lave and Wenger (1991) conceptualise learning as social, occurring through participation in a shared professional community. As Skarli and Stokke (2026) note, such learning is bound up with shared practices, identities and meanings rather than with isolated knowledge acquisition. Seen this way, a placement is more than a site where a student practises. It is a community in which universities, practice educators, field supervisors and students must share expectations and work together. When the links between these actors are weak, the community fragments, and students’ learning suffers with it.

African scholarship shows how this fragmentation plays out where the profession and its institutions are still taking shape. Studies report inconsistent placement durations across universities, shortages of qualified field educators and trained supervisors, and weak communication between universities and agencies (Dhemba, 2012). Gray et al. (2017) similarly identified competition for placements, inconsistent supervision and guidance, inadequately prepared agency supervisors, and overloaded faculty liaisons as constraints on field education in Southern and East Africa. For example, a study in Ethiopia highlighted the misalignment between universities and field agencies, unclear supervisory expectations, and unequal supervision workloads (Amanu and Aredo, 2022). Similar issues have been documented in South Africa, where supervisors emphasise the need for stronger university engagement, clearer guidelines, and structured capacity-building programmes (Thaver, 2012).

Malawi fits this pattern, but the evidence base is thin. Because social work is young in the country, there is little context-specific literature on field education. Wizi-Kambala (2024) identifies the lack of a common field curriculum, inadequate time allocated to field placement, limited assessment by university and field supervisors, inconsistent placement durations and a lack of resources. In Shulman’s terms, these are weaknesses in the structure of the signature pedagogy. In Lave and Wenger’s terms, they point to a community of practice that has yet to cohere. They also mirror the wider position of a profession that has made real progress but still struggles for public recognition and societal trust, and whose curriculum content varies widely across universities (Ndala, 2025; Wizi-Kambala, 2024). Such challenges call for context-based and evidence-based solutions (Kakowa, 2016; Ndala, 2025). Who is better placed to inform those solutions than the practice educators and field supervisors who sustain placements day to day? This article turns to their feedback.

Methodology

The study employed a qualitative descriptive design. This design aims to provide a comprehensive summary of events in everyday language, rather than a highly theorised interpretation (Sandelowski, 2000). It suits the present inquiry because the findings are also intended for non-academic stakeholders, who benefit from issues being presented in everyday language. The study drew on feedback that practice educators and field supervisors provided during a structured training and feedback workshop in Liwonde, Malawi. The University of Malawi’s Department of Sociology and Population Studies organised the workshop, and the author was one of the facilitators. The workshop is the department’s yearly training and feedback workshop for practice educators and field supervisors. It trains them in good practice in student assessment. It also gives the department a platform to gather their feedback on how to improve the practicum. The study draws on the notes and minutes that were taken in that workshop, as archival documents. As a facilitator, the author was close to the workshop and its participants; to limit the influence of this closeness, interpretations were grounded in participants’ contributions as captured in the notes and minutes.

The participants were the 24 practice educators and field supervisors who attended the practice educators’ training held in Liwonde in May 2024. They came from all three regions of Malawi and represented agencies that host social work students from the University of Malawi and other universities. The participants comprised both experienced and new field supervisors and practice educators, and they ranged from top managers to line supervisors.

Feedback was gathered through plenary and participatory reflection sessions held after each workshop session, in which participants reflected on their supervisory and practice educator roles, the challenges facing the social work field practicum, and possible solutions. In the process, the facilitators collected notes and compiled minutes, which were later used for this study. The feedback and reflective sessions provided an open, interactive platform in which participants built on each other’s ideas (Sachdeva et al., 2024), generating rich data that would be difficult to obtain through individual interviews. No separate groups were formed. Eight reflection sessions were held, each lasting between 15 and 30 minutes. Audio was not recorded. The notes and minutes were originally taken for the department’s future planning and were available to the participants.

The data were analysed using Braun and Clarke’s (2006) thematic analysis approach. The analysis followed several steps. First, the notes and minutes, which were in the form of archival records, were read repeatedly to achieve familiarisation. Second, initial codes were generated and collated into preliminary themes, which were then refined into final themes reflecting the shared feedback. More than one note-taker recorded the notes and minutes as routine departmental records. Having several independent records of the same sessions supported the credibility of the findings. Grounding interpretations in participants’ contributions supported confirmability.

Findings

Participants’ feedback converged on five concerns. They wanted placements harmonised across institutions, communication and feedback that arrive in good time, lighter paperwork, clearer expectations, and more regular collaboration with universities. Taken together, these concerns describe a placement system that lacks shared rules and regular contact between universities and host agencies.

Harmonisation of the Social Work Field Practicum

Participants described inconsistencies in how placements are managed across the institutions that offer social work in Malawi, mainly in placement duration, student supervision, and the mode and nature of assessment. Placement length was not standard: some students stay only briefly, while others stay three months or longer. Assessments also vary: some universities use a single simple assessment, while others spread several assessments across the placement. On supervision by university staff, participants noted that not all universities visit their students on placement, and those that do vary in how often. These inconsistencies make students harder to manage, because supervisors must apply different standards to different students. One field supervisor summarised this:

We receive different students from different universities. All these universities have different requirements. Sometimes it becomes confusing and problematic to us as supervisors, especially if we have all these students at once. (Field supervisor)

To address these inconsistencies, participants recommended harmonising social work placements through national placement guidelines that would apply to all placements in Malawi. The guidelines should, among other things, specify placement duration and assessment methods, to ensure fairness and quality across institutions.

Strengthening Communication and Feedback

Poor communication compounded these inconsistencies. Participants were concerned that some universities send notice only just before the event concerned, such as a supervision visit, leaving field supervisors little time to prepare. As one participant observed:

Universities have to work on the issue of communication. Tell us in advance, at least two weeks prior, that you will be visiting us and your students. Sometimes we may assign the students a field activity, and if you just tell us a day before, it becomes challenging to get all the students who were away to be around the office for your visits. (Field supervisor)

Participants also noted that universities rarely give them feedback after a placement, so they do not know whether they have performed their tasks as required. They asked for feedback, positive or negative, that they could use to improve their work. One practice educator (PE) said:

I have just heard here that some students complained to you about the conduct of some supervisors or PEs. But we don’t get such feedback ourselves. Please at the end of the placement, share all the feedback with us. It’s good for us as well. (Practice educator)

Participants recommended timely communication and structured feedback after each placement cycle to improve the quality of supervision.

Minimising and Simplifying Paperwork

Participants also found the paperwork heavy. They reported that the placement paperwork, especially the University of Malawi’s, could overwhelm new supervisors because it was long and complicated. Since supervisors already have their own work, the forms add to their burden, and participants recommended shorter, simpler versions. As one supervisor put it:

The first time I had students from your university, I was surprised with the amount of paper work students had to handle and things I had to go through and sign for them...I kept on postponing it. Maybe shorter version would be ideal, especially for us (Field supervisor)

Clarifying Expectations

Roles were a further source of confusion. Participants reported a lack of clarity about the roles and expectations of field supervisors and practice educators, and about what was expected of students. Where the practice educator and the field supervisor were different people, their roles could be confused, with one doing what the other was supposed to do. Participants therefore recommended clear guidelines defining the roles of the agency supervisor and the practice educator, so that each operates within their mandate.

They also indicated that, because each university has its own placement expectations, agency supervisors are sometimes unsure what they may and may not ask of students. For example, some organisations work on Saturdays, but some students have objected to weekend work, saying they need the time for their university assignments. Without clear expectations, supervisors were unsure how to handle such situations.

A related issue was field allowances. Some organisations pay their employees allowances for work outside the office but make no such provision for students, who are not employees. This created a dilemma, because students still had to go into the field and work for the organisation. One supervisor said:

I think you have to be very clear of how we have to handle the issue of student allowances. Some have been accusing us that we send them to the field without allowances. But such allowances have to be accounted for. They need to be used by the employees. We need guidance on how to handle the issue of student allowances (Field supervisor)

There was also confusion about reporting. Field supervisors called for clear reporting channels for students on placement, clarifying, for example, which issues students should report to university coordinators, and whether they should do so directly or through agency supervisors. If a student needs sick leave, for instance, should the university or the agency grant it? Participants recommended that universities clarify these reporting mechanisms.

Increasing Collaboration and Meetings

Finally, participants called for more collaboration and more frequent meetings between faculty members and agency supervisors. The University of Malawi currently hosts an annual interface meeting with social work agencies, but participants felt that meetings should be held more often and that other universities offering social work should hold them too. They valued these meetings as a platform for learning about emerging issues in field supervision and about good practice in student supervision and assessment. One practice educator said:

I am a new practice educator and this meeting has been an eye-opener. If we can have more of these, it would really be helpful for us. I have gone through placement as a student, but then, this meeting has made me understand student placement differently (New practice educator)

Participants also emphasised collaboration in research. Supervisors noted that they gather a great deal of data in their practice but lack the expertise to turn it into publishable research. They recommended that universities hold dedicated engagement meetings to develop such data into journal articles, and that the annual meeting include training in academic writing and publishing.

Discussion

Harmonisation and Standardisation

In this context, harmonisation means a common standard operating procedure for field placements across all universities offering social work. The findings show that field placement in Malawi faces several challenges as the profession, still relatively young, continues to grow (Ndala, 2025). Similar challenges exist in other African countries where social work is still developing. For example, Dhemba (2012) reports that fieldwork at some social work training institutions in Eastern and Southern Africa lacks a fieldwork curriculum and that agency supervisors are not trained, which is consistent with the present findings.

Calls for harmonisation are important because they could create common benchmarks for all universities offering social work in Malawi, which would in turn strengthen the credibility of, and trust in, Malawi’s social work graduates, whichever university they attended. Major disparities in curriculum risk undermining the credibility of the profession (IASSW & IFSW, 2020). These calls are consistent with the international standards of social work education and training that emphasise the need for consistency and sufficient duration of placements (Ioakimidis and Sookraj, 2021). The Global Standards for Social Work Education and Training recognise fieldwork as a critical component of social work education. They recommend that at least 25% of the overall education activity be counted as practice placement (IASSW & IFSW, 2020).

From a communities of practice perspective (Lave and Wenger, 1991), the lack of harmonised national standards matters because it weakens Malawi’s emerging professional learning community. Because a community of practice rests on shared norms, common practices, and collective meaning-making, fragmented field education across universities produces fragmented communities. A unified placement system across universities, guided by common standards, would help build a cohesive national learning network with shared structures.

From a signature pedagogy perspective, without national placement standards, or minimum standards for social work education generally, the practicum in Malawi risks failing in its function as a signature pedagogy, because students in different institutions are not exposed to equivalent learning conditions.

Communication and Feedback Gap

Participants were also concerned about inefficient communication and feedback between universities and field supervisors, a finding consistent with several other studies. In Ethiopia, Amanu and Aredo (2022) found that weak communication between universities and field supervisors reduced the support students received during field education. Rambabu and Mohan (2018) reported similar findings in India and concluded that stronger communication channels improve collaboration and student supervision. The picture appears different where social work is well established: an online survey of students and field supervisors in Australia found that most supervisors were satisfied with their communication with the university (Pack, 2018).

Weak communication is likely to disrupt the relational learning networks that are essential to field education. Through a communities of practice lens, ongoing engagement, dialogue, and joint problem-solving are critical to learning, so a lack of communication or feedback may leave field supervisors and practice educators as peripheral participants rather than full members of the professional learning community.

From a signature pedagogy perspective, communication between universities and field supervisors may be understood as ‘backstage scaffolding’. This study uses the term to describe the less visible institutional and relational supports that enable student learning during the practicum. Effective field education requires universities to articulate expectations, model reflective practice, and provide timely guidance (Shulman, 2005; Bogo, 2015). Poor communication is likely to weaken these pedagogical foundations and so harm students’ field learning experiences.

Paperwork and Assessment Burden

The heavy paperwork in the University of Malawi’s field assessment echoes wider debates about documentation burdens and workload in social work practice. Simplified documentation would increase compliance and efficiency (Bogo et al., 2022). Clarifying expectations is also particularly important in Malawi, especially for new supervisors, which highlights the need for capacity building (Ketner et al., 2017).

Overwhelming paperwork is likely to reduce the time and effort supervisors put into supervision, undermining student learning. This may explain why some supervisors said that they postponed reviewing the paperwork with students when it overwhelmed them, even though the paperwork structured their supervisory relationship. As Bogo (2015) notes, field assessment should focus on core capacities such as reflective judgement, the integration of knowledge and practice, and professional reasoning. Excessive and complicated paperwork undermines these aims by shifting supervisors’ and students’ attention from learning to bureaucratic requirements. By contrast, streamlined and standardised assessment tools would strengthen both the coherence of the community of practice and the integrity of the signature pedagogy.

From a communities of practice perspective, assessment tools can function as ‘boundary objects’ (Star and Griesemer, 1989; Wenger, 1998) that facilitate shared understanding between academics and field supervisors. When such tools are cumbersome, they may fail to support collaboration and may inhibit learning, which may also explain why some supervisors, particularly new ones, struggle with the current documentation.

Clear Expectations

The need for clear expectations and roles is consistent with findings from other contexts. In Pack’s (2018) study of field supervisors’ and students’ practicum experiences, some supervisors reported a lack of clear guidelines on the functions they were expected to perform. Bogo (2013) similarly points to role confusion among field educators and supervisors, especially when field educators work with several students at the same time. These findings show that universities need clear placement guidelines to avoid such confusion. The University of Malawi has developed field education guidelines (University of Malawi, 2014), but they need to be updated to address current and emerging issues.

A community of practice requires clear roles and mutual accountability. When field supervisors and practice educators do not know what is expected of them, their participation in the learning community becomes fragmented. This should be understood not as a failure of individual supervisors but as a structural issue, stemming from the lack of a national supervision framework setting out clear expectations for everyone involved in student placements.

Stronger Collaborations

Field supervisors’ call for more frequent in-person meetings and collaboration with universities shows their commitment to strengthening the partnership and their willingness to develop professionally, since such meetings are also a way of sharing good practice in student supervision. In Pack’s (2018) study, field supervisors likewise asked universities for more training to help them support students on placement. In South Africa, supervisors also called for stronger collaboration with universities, including shared training, regular forums, and opportunities for universities and host agencies to develop supervision frameworks jointly, as a way of enhancing both student field education and agencies’ supervisory support (Thaver, 2012).

Collaboration in research is also important for social work education and practice in Malawi, which currently has little locally generated social work literature. Collaborative research would be one of the best ways to build a body of local, evidence-based literature (Kakowa, 2016; Ndala, 2025).

Supervisors’ wish for more meetings and training aligns with both theoretical frameworks. From a communities of practice perspective, regular interaction and shared learning help build a robust professional community. From a signature pedagogy perspective, such workshops are collaborative learning spaces in which supervisors acquire knowledge that is eventually passed on to students.

 

Implications and Recommendations

Policy Recommendations

The findings suggest several policy recommendations. The most urgent is to develop national minimum standards for field education, applicable to all universities offering social work in Malawi, possibly as part of broader minimum standards for social work education and training. This would ensure equity across universities in how field placements are implemented. At the time of writing (2025), the Social Workers Practitioners Bill had not yet been passed in Parliament. Among other things, it provides for the establishment of a social work council, which Malawi does not currently have and will not have until the bill is assented to and becomes law. As in countries where social work is well established, this could be achieved by creating a social work council to regulate social work practice, working with ASWiM, the responsible ministries, and the National Council for Higher Education (NCHE). An Association of Schools of Social Work in Malawi could also be established to coordinate universities and agencies, ensuring smooth implementation of the field practicum and facilitating regular meetings between universities offering social work and host agencies.

Academic Recommendations

For academia, the study recommends a national supervision framework for social work field education that clearly defines the roles, reporting channels, and minimum expectations of practice educators and field supervisors. The framework could form part of the minimum standards for social work education and training and would help make placement implementation consistent across universities. The study also recommends introducing field education and supervision theory into the social work curriculum to equip graduates, who are often engaged as practice educators, with the necessary educational and supervisory skills.

Practice Recommendations

In practice, regular continuing professional development workshops are needed for field supervisors and practice educators to keep them up to date with new developments and good practice in student supervision. Such workshops would resolve some of the confusion supervisors face and give them the confidence and autonomy to handle dilemmas when university staff are not immediately available.

Conclusion

Field education is a core component of social work education worldwide. It is well established where the profession is mature, but not yet in many developing countries where social work is new. In Malawi, student placements face several challenges, chief among them the absence of minimum field standards for all universities to follow. Global guidelines exist but have not been adapted to national contexts, leaving field education fragmented across institutions. The insights of field supervisors and practice educators point to five areas that must be addressed if field education in Malawi is to improve: harmonised practicum standards; better communication between universities and agencies; simplified documentation; clearer expectations of the roles of field supervisors and practice educators; and more frequent collaboration between universities and the field.

REFERENCE ID: MJSS-2026-357

Article metrics

Published on: November 20, 2026

32

Views

7

Downloads

0

Citations

Related Content

For Latest Updates Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Select the fields to be shown. Others will be hidden. Drag and drop to rearrange the order.
  • Image
  • SKU
  • Rating
  • Price
  • Stock
  • Availability
  • Add to cart
  • Weight
  • Dimensions
  • Additional information
Click outside to hide the comparison bar
Compare